High Fructose Corn Syrup: Effects & Diet

By Steve Gendron, Ph.D.
Explore the sweet saga of high fructose corn syrup, from its roots to its role in our diets and the importance of moderation in its consumption.
*This page may include affiliate links; that means we earn from qualifying purchases of products.
Chances are you’ve heard of high fructose corn syrup (HFCS). It's that sweet talker in your sodas and snacks that makes everything taste oh so good. Born from corn and tweaked by science, HFCS is a mix of fructose and glucose, sweetening our lives since the 1970s. But as its fame has grown, so have the health debates surrounding it. Stick around as we unpack the sweet and not-so-sweet sides of HFCS.
​Before reading on, if you're a therapist, coach, or wellness entrepreneur, be sure to grab our free Wellness Business Growth eBook to get expert tips and free resources that will help you grow your business exponentially.​​​​​​​​​
Are You a Therapist, Coach, or Wellness Entrepreneur?

Grab Our Free eBook to Learn How to
Grow Your Wellness Business Exponentially!

 ✓  Save hundreds of hours of time  ✓  Earn more $ faster  
​✓  Boost your credibility ✓  Deliver high-impact content 

What Is High Fructose Corn Syrup? (A Definition)

So you've probably heard of high fructose corn syrup (HFCS) and seen it listed on a ton of food labels, but what exactly is it? Well, let's break it down in simpler terms. Imagine corn decided to go on a sweet adventure, transforming from its usual self into something super sweet. That's essentially what HFCS is—a sweetener made from corn (White, 2008).

Here's how it works: Scientists take cornstarch, which is just a bunch of molecules of glucose (a type of sugar) hanging out together. They convert some of that glucose into fructose, another type of sugar that's naturally quite sweet. The end result is this syrupy liquid that's got a mix of both fructose and glucose in it. The most common mixes you'll find are HFCS 55, which is super popular in sodas and has a bit more fructose, and HFCS 42, which you'll find in baked goodies.

Back in the '70s, food manufacturers hit the jackpot with HFCS because it was cheaper than regular sugar, it was super sweet, and it mixed easily into drinks and foods (White, 2008). Plus it made things like your favorite soda have a longer shelf life and kept your cookies soft and fresh. So it's no surprise it started popping up everywhere—from drinks to snacks and even in things you wouldn't expect, like ketchup.​

But as much as HFCS sounds like the ultimate sweet solution, there's been a lot of talk about its health impacts, sparking a whole lot of research and debate. As we dive deeper into what HFCS does to our health, keep in mind that it's all about understanding what's in our food and making choices that fit our lifestyle.

History of High Fructose Corn Syrup​

Think back to the '70s, a time of disco and innovation—including the birth of HFCS. Scientists figured out how to take corn, a super cheap crop, and turn it into a sweetener that could compete with sugar without breaking the bank. It was a big deal because sugar prices were going through the roof, and everyone was on the hunt for a cheaper sweet fix (High Fructose Corn Syrup, 2024).

The real breakthrough came when Japanese scientists upped the game by making HFCS even sweeter and cheaper. Suddenly HFCS was the cool new thing, especially for soda and snack companies looking to save some money.

By the '80s, HFCS was everywhere. It was like the smartphone of sweeteners, popping up in everything from your favorite fizzy drinks to bread and even condiments like salsa.

But as HFCS took over the world, people started to wonder if it was too good to be true. Health debates kicked in, with folks questioning if HFCS was the bad guy behind rising obesity rates and other health woes.​

Fast forward to today, and HFCS is kind of like that catchy song everyone knows but has mixed feelings about. Some people steer clear, looking for other ways to sweeten their life, while others just shrug and enjoy their sweet treats as they are.

So, there's the down-and-dirty story of HFCS—a sweet solution that turned into a bit of a sticky situation.

How Is High Fructose Corn Syrup Produced?

The making of HFCS is not exactly kitchen science, but let's break it down. Picture a bunch of scientists and big machines taking ordinary corn and turning it into something super sweet. 

First up, you start with cornstarch. It's pretty bland on its own, right? Well, this cornstarch gets a makeover with some enzymes called alpha-amylase. Think of them as little helpers that kickstart a transformation. These enzymes get to work chopping up the starch into something called glucose (Parker et al., 2010). But we're not done yet.

Here's where it gets interesting. Another set of enzymes called glucoamylase comes into play, turning some of that glucose into fructose, which is a fancy name for fruit sugar. It's this switcheroo from glucose to fructose that gives HFCS its sweet personality, making it a hit in the sweetener world.

After some stirring, heating, and enzyme action, what started as plain old cornstarch is now HFCS, ready to sweeten up your favorite drinks and snacks. And there you have it, the lowdown on how HFCS is whipped up—a little bit of science, a dash of corn, and a whole lot of sweetness (Parker et al., 2010).​

High Fructose Corn Syrup Products

Where does this popular but controversial sweetener actually kick back and relax in the grocery store? Let's take a quick tour through the aisles and spot some of HFCS's favorite hangouts (Ng et al., 2012):

  • Soda & sweet drinks: The number one spot to find HFCS chilling is in the soda aisle. It's like the VIP lounge for HFCS, which gives all those fizzy drinks their signature sweet taste.  
  • Snack foods: From cookies to snack bars and even some breads, HFCS sneaks into a lot of our snack time favorites, keeping things sweet and shelf stable.  
  • Condiments: This might surprise you, but ketchup, barbecue sauce, and salad dressings often invite HFCS to their flavor party, and it makes them tastier and thicker.  
  • Canned fruits: Fruits packed in syrup can sometimes get a little boost from HFCS, which keeps them preserved and sweet in their cans.  
  • Frozen foods: From frozen pizzas to ready-to-eat meals, HFCS often pops up in these ingredient lists, adding flavor and a touch of sweetness.  
  • Dairy products: Flavored yogurts and some ice creams use HFCS as a sweetener, which makes them irresistibly creamy and sweet.

​So next time you're wandering through the grocery store, keep an eye out for HFCS. It's everywhere, mingling with your favorite foods and drinks, adding that sweet touch we often crave. Just remember, everything in moderation.

Why Is High Fructose Corn Syrup Bad for You?

Now let's chat about the controversial side of HFCS, that omnipresent sweetener that's been stirring up quite the debate. Is it a villain in disguise or just misunderstood? Here's the scoop, blending both the reasons it might be bad news and the side effects that could follow if you're on a first-name basis with HFCS.

  • Waistline alert: Think of HFCS as that friend who always insists on just one more episode during a binge-watching session. Seems fun, but your waistline might not thank you. Overdoing it with HFCS can lead to unwanted weight gain (Jung et al., 2022).​  
  • Mood swings & energy dips: HFCS has a way of taking your blood sugar on a joyride; the highs are followed by lows, leaving you more crashed out than after a bad movie marathon. It's a real rollercoaster, minus the fun photo at the end.  
  • Your liver's not a fan: Picture your liver as a diligent worker trying to keep up with the incoming emails (in this case, fructose). Too much HFCS can make it seem like your liver's inbox is exploding, potentially leading to fatty liver issues such as nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (Yu et al., 2021) and type 2 diabetes (Hattori et al., 2021). Talk about needing an out-of-office reply.  
  • Heart health drama: HFCS sneaks into your heart's DMs, but not in a good way. It can play a part in upping those triglyceride levels, making it the kind of drama your heart definitely doesn't need (Jung et al., 2022).  
  • The never-ending sugar saga: Ever notice how the more sweets you eat, the more you crave? HFCS can turn you into a real-life Cookie Monster, always on the hunt for the next sugar fix. Breaking up with sugar becomes as tough as getting over your first crush (Lowette et al., 2015).  
  • Kidney concerns: HFCS might be playing a shady role in the health of your kidneys. Studies hint at a link between chugging down those sugary drinks and not-so-great news like chronic kidney disease (Shoham et  al., 2008) and kidney stones (Taylor & Curhan, 2008).  
  • Cancer connection: Here's where things get even stickier. Fructose, the main star in HFCS, has been linked to various types of cancers. It seems tumor cells might be using fructose as a fuel source, with studies suggesting a strong association between fructose consumption and the risk of pancreatic tumors, especially in folks with obesity and those who aren’t very active (Jung et al., 2022). 

In essence, while HFCS might make everything taste like a dream, it's worth considering if it's a dream or a bit of a nightmare for your health. Like all indulgences, enjoying it in moderation is key—because who wants to give up on life's sweet moments entirely? Not us, that's for sure.​

Sensitivity to High Fructose Corn Syrup​

Ever had that not-so-great gut feeling after diving into a sweet treat? You might be experiencing the joys of fructose malabsorption, a fancy term for when your body plays hardball with the fructose in HFCS. Let's break it down (Ebert & Witt, 2016; Putkonen et al., 2013):

  • The gut rebellion: Imagine your intestines hosting a party, and fructose shows up uninvited. Instead of digesting it smoothly, your gut decides it's not having any of it, leading to bloating, pain, and a trip to the bathroom faster than you can say "no more sweets for me, thanks."​  
  • The sweet overload: HFCS is like that overeager friend who doesn't know when to stop. It loads your system with fructose, and if you're one of the unlucky ones with fructose malabsorption, your body might react with a resounding "I can't even."  
  • The symptoms speak volumes: If, after enjoying something sweet, you find yourself feeling like a balloon ready to pop, experiencing the joy of digestive discomfort, or even getting those fun mood swings and energy crashes, HFCS might be your frenemy.  
  • Listen to your body: It's all about tuning in to what your body's telling you. If it seems like every time you indulge in an HFCS-laden snack, you're not feeling your best, it might be time to consider that sensitivity a bit more seriously.  
  • Navigating the sweet waters: Finding out you're sensitive to HFCS isn't the end of the world. It's like discovering you're allergic to cats and then deciding maybe a goldfish is more your speed. There are plenty of other ways to enjoy the sweet life without upsetting your gut.

So if HFCS and your body are not exactly on speaking terms, it's okay. It's just a sign to explore the vast world of sweeteners out there and find what makes your gut (and you) happiest. Remember, you're in charge of the guest list for the party in your gut.

High Fructose Corn Syrup and Your Glycemic Index

Alright, let's get into the nitty-gritty of HFCS and that whole blood sugar drama. You've heard of the glycemic index (GI), right? It's basically a scorecard that tells us how quickly food sends our blood sugar levels on a rollercoaster ride. So where does HFCS fit into this picture? Let's break it down, no lab coat required (Schaefer et al., 2009):

  • Not so fast, buddy: Despite what its name might suggest, HFCS isn't the main villain in the "spike your blood sugar" saga. Thanks to fructose (its smoother, slower partner in crime), HFCS doesn't make your blood sugar levels skyrocket as quickly as some other sweet bad boys. It's more like a leisurely stroll than a sprint.​  
  • The dynamic duo: HFCS is a bit like a buddy cop movie, with glucose and fructose teaming up. Glucose is all about that quick action, while fructose takes its sweet time. The result? A mixed bag when it comes to messing with your glycemic index.  
  • Hold the celebration: Before you start high-fiving HFCS for not being a total blood sugar bully, remember that this doesn't mean it's your new best friend. Going overboard with the sweet stuff can still lead to trouble in paradise, like making your body less able to handle sugar and adding extra padding to your waistline.  
  • Everything in moderation: Just like binge-watching your favorite series, a little goes a long way. Enjoying HFCS in moderation means you can still have your cake (or soda) and eat it too, without turning your blood sugar levels into a plot twist.

So there you have it: HFCS and blood sugar levels have a complicated relationship. It's not all doom and gloom, but it's not a fairy tale either. Keeping a balanced diet is like curating the perfect playlist—it's all about the mix.​

Is High Fructose Corn Syrup Worse Than Sugar?

So, is HFCS worse than sucrose (the scientific name for sugar)? It's kind of like asking if a tornado is worse than a hurricane: Both can mess up your picnic. They've been stirring up quite the debate in the health and nutrition world, especially when it comes to their roles in metabolism and the ever-growing obesity saga.

Sweet Similarities & Slight Differences

Both HFCS and sucrose pack the same caloric punch and bring equal levels of sweetness to the table. But when it comes to what happens after they crash the party, things get a bit more complicated. Sucrose, being the balanced type, splits into equal parts glucose and fructose during digestion. HFCS, on the other hand, rolls in already split up, with its most popular form, HFCS 55, rocking about 55% fructose and 45% glucose.

The Health Chat

Chowing down on too much of either can lead you down a not-so-sweet path filled with tooth decay, nutritional no-nos, and a hike in triglyceride levels (which could nudge you closer to heart disease territory). Some finger-pointing has been directed at fructose, especially when it's partying hard in HFCS, linking it to liver fat, insulin resistance, and the dreaded metabolic syndrome (Stricker et al., 2021). But when the music stops and everyone goes home, the evidence doesn't quite show HFCS as the main villain over sucrose, especially in the amounts most folks consume.

Metabolism Mix-Up

Here's where the plot thickens: Glucose and fructose have different dance moves when it comes to metabolism. Glucose is the energy of the party, used by nearly every cell, and it knows how to keep blood sugar levels in check. Fructose prefers to hang out in the liver, possibly kicking off fat production and playing into nonalcoholic fatty liver disease and insulin resistance (Hattori et al., 2021; Yu et al., 2021).

Compared to sucrose, HFCS has a higher ratio of fructose to glucose. This has caused some raised eyebrows about its metabolic effects. But since sucrose also brings fructose to the dance floor, the difference in their moves might not be as dramatic as some think, assuming one isn’t constantly hogging the spotlight (Li et al., 2022).

The Obesity Plot

The rise in obesity has been linked to our love affair with added sugars, including both HFCS and sucrose. There's chatter about the body handling fructose differently, perhaps leading to a never-ending appetite and eventual weight gain. Yet pinning down HFCS as the lead culprit in obesity hasn't been a slam dunk. It seems the real drama is in the overeating of any calories, not just those from HFCS or sucrose (Li et al., 2022).

Wrapping It Up

The bottom line is, overdosing on any added sweetener—be it HFCS, sugar, or even those that sound fancy and healthy—is not going to score you any health points. It's all about how much you're consuming rather than picking sides in the sweetener saga.

Just like with anything in life, the secret sauce is moderation. Enjoying a soda or a cookie isn't going to derail your health train. But making them a daily guest star in your diet? That's when you might start seeing some plot twists in your health story.​

Video: What’s the Difference Between Sugar and High Fructose Corn Syrup?

High Fructose Corn Syrup Withdrawal Symptoms

Want to cut back on HFCS and wondering what the ride might be like? You're not alone. While there's not a ton of research on HFCS withdrawal by itself, we can get a pretty good idea by looking at what sugar withdrawal is like, since HFCS is a big player in the added sugars game.

How Long Will This Last?

The whole "how long" question can depend on a few things: how much HFCS you were used to, your body's own metabolism, and what the rest of your diet and lifestyle look like. Generally, those sugar withdrawal symptoms could kick in a few days after you cut back, and they may stick around for a few days to a couple of weeks. And yep, for some folks, those cravings and some minor symptoms might linger for a bit longer (DiNicolantonio et al., 2018).

What's the Deal with Symptoms?

When you start saying "no thanks" to HFCS, here are some ways your body might respond:

  • Sweet cravings: You could experience a strong desire for all things sweet.  
  • Mood rollercoaster: You might find yourself feeling irritable, anxious, or just mood-swingy.  
  • The tireds: You might have less energy and feel kind of blah.  
  • Headache city: You could get more headaches or even migraines.  
  • Brain fog: You might feel like your thinking is not as sharp or have trouble focusing.  
  • Appetite whiplash: You could be hungrier than usual, or you might sometimes not feel like eating at all.

Severity: A Personal Journey

How rough it feels can really vary. Some might breeze through with barely a hiccup, while others might find it's messing with their daily groove. Often, the more HFCS you were eating before, the more noticeable the changes might be when you cut back.

The Balanced Approach

While kicking HFCS to the curb can be a good move for your health, it's all about finding that balanced approach to what you eat. If you're thinking of making changes, it might be a good idea to chat with a healthcare pro or a nutritionist. They can give you the lowdown on how to make these changes in a way that's best for you, helping smooth out those withdrawal bumps along the way.

If you're gearing up to give HFCS the boot, remember: It's a journey. There might be a few bumps along the way, but understanding what's coming can help you prepare and make the transition a whole lot smoother.

High Fructose Corn Syrup Replacements

So you're thinking it's time to break up with high fructose corn syrup (HFCS), but you’re not sure who's waiting in the wings to take its place. No worries; the dating pool for sweeteners is pretty large, and we've got some top contenders ready to sweet talk their way into your heart (and pantry). Let's meet the lineup:

  • Honey, darling: First up, we have honey—natural, sweet, and with a touch of floral notes that can make any dish or drink feel a bit more gourmet. Plus it's packed with antioxidants. Just remember: It's still a sweetener, so don't go overboard.  
  • Maple syrup—oh, Canada: Then there's maple syrup, which not only scores points for flavor but also brings minerals like zinc and manganese to the table. It's like HFCS's sophisticated cousin who studied abroad.  
  • Agave nectar, sweet and slick: Agave nectar comes from the same plant that gives us tequila, so it's already got some fun vibes going. It's sweeter than HFCS, so you can use less of it, but it's high in fructose, so keep that in mind.  
  • Stevia, the zero-cal hero: Looking for something without the calories? Stevia might be your match. It's a natural sweetener from the leaves of the stevia plant, and it's super sweet without the calorie price tag. Just be mindful of the aftertaste that some folks notice.  
  • Dates, the sweet spot: Dates are like nature's candy and can be blended into a paste that's perfect for sweetening up smoothies, baked goods, and more. Plus they pack fiber and nutrients along with their sweetness.  
  • Coconut sugar, a tropical touch: Last but not least, coconut sugar offers a lower GI alternative and adds a hint of caramel-like flavor to your dishes. It's more nutrient-rich than HFCS but still a sugar, so moderation is key.

Switching up your sweetener is like refreshing your dating profile: It's all about finding the right match for you. Each of these alternatives has its own charm and benefits, so play the field, test them out, and see which one makes your taste buds swipe right. Remember, the goal is sweetening up your life in a healthier way, not starting a new sugar dependency. So keep it casual and enjoy the sweetness of exploring your options.​

Is High Fructose Corn Syrup Banned in Europe?

HFCS isn't on the no-fly list in Europe; it's just been playing by a different set of rules (High Fructose Corn Syrup, 2024). Over there, it goes by isoglucose; other names for it are glucose-fructose syrup and fructose-glucose syrup, depending on its composition. For a long time there was a cap on how much could be made, thanks to a quota system. This wasn't about health worries; it was more about keeping the agricultural and economic landscape across EU territories fair and square.

This quota thing started in 2005, then got tweaked in 2007 and 2011 to allow production to ramp up as folks in the EU were wanting more of it. But then, on September 30, 2017, the European Parliament decided to lift the cap as part of a bigger plan to shake up agriculture in an effort to make the sector more efficient and competitive, not out of a lack of concern about health.

In the EU, if HFCS is less fructose-heavy (under 50%), it's called glucose-fructose syrup (GFS). If it's more fructose-heavy (over 50%), it's fructose-glucose syrup (FGS). Part of the reason they lifted the production cap was to cut down on how much sugar they needed to bring in from elsewhere and try to be more self-sufficient.​

The bottom line? HFCS hasn't been banned in Europe. It was just under some strict rules until 2017, but those have been relaxed, opening up the EU market to more HFCS action.

Articles Related to High Fructose Corn Syrup

​Want to learn more? Check out these articles:

Books Related to High Fructose Corn Syrup​

If you’d like to keep learning more, here are a few books that you might be interested in.

Final Thoughts on High Fructose Corn Syrup​

Exploring the world of high fructose corn syrup (HFCS) reveals a blend of innovation, controversy, and calls for moderation. It's a sweet staple with a complex story, reminding us to balance our diets and make informed food choices. As we navigate the sweet landscape, remember: Moderation and awareness are key. HFCS's tale isn't just about sugar; it's about our health and how we choose to sustain it.

Don't Forget to Grab Our Free eBook to Learn How to
Grow Your Wellness Business Exponentially!

References
Are You a Therapist, Coach, or Wellness Entrepreneur?
Grab Our Free eBook to Learn How to Grow Your Wellness Business Fast!
Key Articles:Content Packages:
Terms, Privacy & Affiliate Disclosure  |   Contact   |   FAQs
* The Berkeley Well-Being Institute. LLC is not affiliated with UC Berkeley.
Copyright © 2024, The Berkeley Well-Being Institute, LLC